Hosted by Dailymotion. For legal issues report at the Copyright Center, report us on DMC, or use the Instant Removal tool.
Michio Kaku: Intergalactic "G" Mail
Description
http://bigthink.com
Could the power of gravity be harnessed as a means of nearly instantaneous communication between planets—and even galaxies?
Question: Can we utilize the orbital gravity of the outer planets to propel messages far beyond our solar system? (Submitted by Aaron Anderson)Michio Kaku: Aaron, so many times scientists have wondered is it somehow possible that we can set up an interplanetary communication system so we don't have to wait hours to days for messages to go back and forth within the solar system. For example, if you want to communicate with the Mars Rover sometimes it takes up to 20 minutes, 20 minutes for a signal to go from Earth to Mars—and then another 20 minutes for a message to come back. You certainly cannot carry on a conversation between two people this way.
So some people have said, "What about gravity or what about another way to send messages around the solar system?" Well there is a problem there. First of all, Newton said that gravity moves instantly throughout the solar system. If the sun, for example, were to disappear right now—right now the sun were to disappear, Newton would say that instantly throughout the universe everybody knows that our sun has disappeared. But along comes Einstein who says, "Not so fast. Not so fast. If the sun were to disappear the shockwave of gravity travels at the speed of light." So it would take eight minutes, eight minutes for us to be aware of the fact that our sun has disappeared. So gravity waves also travel at the speed of light. Now, to be, fair no one has ever measured this. I repeat: no one has ever measured the speed of gravity. However, most scientists do believe that gravity travels at the speed of light.
So in other words, to answer your question: we simply don't know of a communication system that would allow us to link up all the planets of the solar system instantly. Light can't do it. Gravity can't do it. We're faced with the fact that Einstein is the cop on the block.
Question: Can we utilize the orbital gravity of the outer planets to propel messages far beyond our solar system? (Submitted by Aaron Anderson)Michio Kaku: Aaron, so many times scientists have wondered is it somehow possible that we can set up an interplanetary communication system so we don't have to wait hours to days for messages to go back and forth within the solar system. For example, if you want to communicate with the Mars Rover sometimes it takes up to 20 minutes, 20 minutes for a signal to go from Earth to Mars—and then another 20 minutes for a message to come back. You certainly cannot carry on a conversation between two people this way.
So some people have said, "What about gravity or what about another way to send messages around the solar system?" Well there is a problem there. First of all, Newton said that gravity moves instantly throughout the solar system. If the sun, for example, were to disappear right now—right now the sun were to disappear, Newton would say that instantly throughout the universe everybody knows that our sun has disappeared. But along comes Einstein who says, "Not so fast. Not so fast. If the sun were to disappear the shockwave of gravity travels at the speed of light." So it would take eight minutes, eight minutes for us to be aware of the fact that our sun has disappeared. So gravity waves also travel at the speed of light. Now, to be, fair no one has ever measured this. I repeat: no one has ever measured the speed of gravity. However, most scientists do believe that gravity travels at the speed of light.
So in other words, to answer your question: we simply don't know of a communication system that would allow us to link up all the planets of the solar system instantly. Light can't do it. Gravity can't do it. We're faced with the fact that Einstein is the cop on the block.
Could the power of gravity be harnessed as a means of nearly instantaneous communication between planets—and even galaxies?
Question: Can we utilize the orbital gravity of the outer planets to propel messages far beyond our solar system? (Submitted by Aaron Anderson)Michio Kaku: Aaron, so many times scientists have wondered is it somehow possible that we can set up an interplanetary communication system so we don't have to wait hours to days for messages to go back and forth within the solar system. For example, if you want to communicate with the Mars Rover sometimes it takes up to 20 minutes, 20 minutes for a signal to go from Earth to Mars—and then another 20 minutes for a message to come back. You certainly cannot carry on a conversation between two people this way.
So some people have said, "What about gravity or what about another way to send messages around the solar system?" Well there is a problem there. First of all, Newton said that gravity moves instantly throughout the solar system. If the sun, for example, were to disappear right now—right now the sun were to disappear, Newton would say that instantly throughout the universe everybody knows that our sun has disappeared. But along comes Einstein who says, "Not so fast. Not so fast. If the sun were to disappear the shockwave of gravity travels at the speed of light." So it would take eight minutes, eight minutes for us to be aware of the fact that our sun has disappeared. So gravity waves also travel at the speed of light. Now, to be, fair no one has ever measured this. I repeat: no one has ever measured the speed of gravity. However, most scientists do believe that gravity travels at the speed of light.
So in other words, to answer your question: we simply don't know of a communication system that would allow us to link up all the planets of the solar system instantly. Light can't do it. Gravity can't do it. We're faced with the fact that Einstein is the cop on the block.
Question: Can we utilize the orbital gravity of the outer planets to propel messages far beyond our solar system? (Submitted by Aaron Anderson)Michio Kaku: Aaron, so many times scientists have wondered is it somehow possible that we can set up an interplanetary communication system so we don't have to wait hours to days for messages to go back and forth within the solar system. For example, if you want to communicate with the Mars Rover sometimes it takes up to 20 minutes, 20 minutes for a signal to go from Earth to Mars—and then another 20 minutes for a message to come back. You certainly cannot carry on a conversation between two people this way.
So some people have said, "What about gravity or what about another way to send messages around the solar system?" Well there is a problem there. First of all, Newton said that gravity moves instantly throughout the solar system. If the sun, for example, were to disappear right now—right now the sun were to disappear, Newton would say that instantly throughout the universe everybody knows that our sun has disappeared. But along comes Einstein who says, "Not so fast. Not so fast. If the sun were to disappear the shockwave of gravity travels at the speed of light." So it would take eight minutes, eight minutes for us to be aware of the fact that our sun has disappeared. So gravity waves also travel at the speed of light. Now, to be, fair no one has ever measured this. I repeat: no one has ever measured the speed of gravity. However, most scientists do believe that gravity travels at the speed of light.
So in other words, to answer your question: we simply don't know of a communication system that would allow us to link up all the planets of the solar system instantly. Light can't do it. Gravity can't do it. We're faced with the fact that Einstein is the cop on the block.
More from User
08:39
Is reality real? These neuroscientists don’t think so.
Big Think
06:37
Your reptilian brain, explained | Robert Sapolsky
Big Think
05:35
3 brain hacks to control your Amazon addiction (from a neuroscientist)
Big Think
06:36
Isolating carbon from human ashes to create diamonds
Big Think
05:28
What charity does to your brain
Big Think
05:49
How to trick your brain into saving money
Big Think
Related Videos
06:20
Dr. Michio Kaku and Cryonics: Why Michio Kaku's Critique of Cryonics is Bogus
Theo Esteban
03:31
Michio Kaku on Physics of the Impossible
drkiki
04:07
Michio Kaku on the Big Bang
drkiki
10:10
Tea with Michio Kaku | The Economist
The Economist
04:03
Michio Kaku On Aliens Physics.. Part 1
barnardclerk
03:12
Michio Kaku: X-Ray Vision and Telepathy Already Exist
Big Think